The prospect of a disruptive U.S. freight railroad strike was averted thanks to the tentative deal reached overnight between the Class I railroads and the labor unions that represent engineers and conductors, but three key questions remain unanswered. And all of them suggest that railroads, their workers, shippers, and the U.S. economy are not out of the woods yet.
First, will the rank-and-file approve the contract? That’s not clear.
Rail labor in general and train crews in particular have been up in arms for the past few years. They’re upset about working conditions, the massive wave of layoffs that began in 2017, and operational changes related to Precision Scheduled Railroading. They’re fuming about the lack of a raise since 2019 despite being front line workers during a pandemic. And they don’t like talk of taking conductors out of the locomotive cab and shifting them to ground-based positions.
The tentative agreement with the SMART-TD union and the Brotherhood of Locomotive Engineers and Trainmen seems to check all the boxes: A 24% raise, compounded, over the five-year life of the contract, plus $5,000 in bonuses; no increase in health care costs; and changes to work rules that provide more guarantees for time off. The deal also includes protections for two-person crews.
But machinists this week rejected the tentative deal their union reached with the railroads last month. The early reaction from the BLET and SMART-TD rank and file is not encouraging. So there’s no guarantee BLET, SMART-TD, and the other nine unions involved in negotiations will ratify their proposed contracts. And that means we could be in for another round of negotiations and more strike drama.
The second question: If the deals win ratification, will engineers and conductors who are tired of their jobs stick around just long enough to pocket their back pay and bonuses and then pull the pin?
If the wages, benefits, and work rules changes are enough of an incentive, they’ll stay on. If not, they’ll take the money and run. So there could be an exodus of engineers and conductors just as BNSF Railway, CSX Transportation, Norfolk Southern, and Union Pacific get close to solving their ongoing crew shortage problems.
This leads us to the third question: Will the new contracts and higher wages be enough to ease the railroads’ conductor recruitment woes?
In an extremely tight job market, railroads have struggled to find new hires for a job that’s 24/7/365, involves working outdoors in all sorts of weather, and requires time spent away from home. It’s not yet clear if the higher wages will lure people away from jobs that pay less but offer predictable schedules and let you sleep in your own bed every night.
These three questions are critical to the industry’s future, both in the short term and over the longer term. If there’s anything crew shortages have proven over the past year, it’s that railroads can’t run well or meet freight demand if they don’t have enough people.
Trains Columnist Bill Stephens
The crew-related service problems at the Big Four U.S. railroads have given the industry a black eye. The uncertainty raised by the prospect of a strike, and the disruption it posed to already frustrated shippers as railroads curtailed some service in preparation for a walkout this week, didn’t help matters.
In the second quarter, the U.S. Class I railroads all reported some combination of record revenue, profits, and earnings despite providing awful service that drove away business and alarmed regulators. It’s as if the railroads have a license to print money.
Yet the industry can ill afford a second wave of crew shortages and crummy service. Some observers fear that shippers who diverted their freight to trucks over the past year may never come back to rail. You shudder to think what would happen if the railroads’ slow but steady pace of operational improvements sputters out because the Big Four systems can’t retain train crews or hire new conductors.
What railroads need now is more stability and less uncertainty. The best way to go about it would be for labor and management to iron out their differences.
Our country is in trouble. The government, the media, and the education system are all controlled by a small number of people who don’t have our best interests at heart.
We're being censored, lied to, and kept in the dark. We need to wake up and take action before it's too late.
Our Locals Community is a safe place for patriots, freedom lovers, and believers who seek truth, knowledge, and real intelligence. Our mission is to arm you with the truth so you can protect your family against what is coming next.
This private, censorship-free community is packed with information about the global fight, plus ways for you to take action and make a difference.
About Jeffrey Prather
Retired Special Operations Soldier, former DIA Intelligence Collector, and ex-DEA Special Agent, Jeffrey Prather, delivers situational awareness and breaks down what’s coming for freedom-loving patriots.
Targeted by the Deep State, Jeffrey became a whistle-blower and refocused his mission to serve you with...
Today on The Prather Point:
HR-1 ends elections!
US cold, China coal-ed!
NATO mobilizes 300K troops!
Irish troubles to US!
Satellite Phone Special Offer Visit http://PratherDeal.com
Save $150 on 3-months of Emergency Food Visit http://PratherPrepSupply.com
Today on The Prather Point LIVE at 2 pm ET on:
TRANNY CATHOLIC KILLER: A JEWISH, SATANIC SET UP!
TRUMP’S FBI-RUN NAT’L GUARD QUICK REACTION FORCE!
PEDO RAPE PIMP MAXWELL MOVED TO MINIMUM SECURITY!
PROJECT GIDEON: MOSSAD PRE-CRIME AI MK-ULTRAS AMERICA!
TRUMP’S GAZA WAR END STARTS KUSHER’S BEACH FRONT BUY UP!
BRETT MILLER USMC VET & GALILEYO CEO’S NEW BOOK ‘POLITICAL INCONTINENCE’!
Having grown up in South Mpls. Minnesota- thru the staged George Floyd- the riots in my neighborhood that were NOT my neighbors but Antifa! Governor Tims stand down on calling in national guard.
Is anyone paying attention to the hit job that happened less than 24 hours before the actual Catholic pre school - 8th grade shooting!???
•Tuesday 8/26th : a man stepped out of a vehicle with a high velocity .223 caliber rifle. Targeted and shot dead one individual then turned his weapon on witnesses of shooting sending 6 to the hospital in critical conditions.
Looks to me like we have a hit job being covered with a False Flag. All within less than 24 hours of each other!! media coverage scripted and prompted for Trani shooter at annunciation Catholic Church! All focus on dead and wounded children!